Evaluating the Synthesis Model of tutoring across the educational spectrum

  • Rebecca Day Babcock Department of Literature and Languages, University of Texas Permian Basin https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9205-9805
  • Aliethia Dean Department of Literature and Languages, University of Texas Permian Basin
  • Victoria Hinesly Departments of Literature and Languages and Psychology, University of Texas Permian Basin
  • Aileen Taft Department of Literature and Languages, University of Texas Permian Basin
Keywords: tutoring, tutoring model, grounded theory, asynchronous tutoring, online tutoring

Abstract

The goal of this study is to verify a grounded theory model of tutoring developed by Babcock, Manning and Rogers (2012) using qualitative research literature as data. The four participants in the current study (three females) were recruited using a convenience sample as they were current or former tutees of the authors. One participant was a middle-school student while the others were college students. To obtain data, participants were tutored by the researchers either online (asynchronously) or face-to-face. Researchers coded the data based on audio recordings of face-to-face sessions and written artefacts of online tutoring sessions. The results support the model developed by Babcock et al. (2012). It is important to verify the grounded theory model since it will close the circle with grounded theory research to apply it to authentic tutoring data. Researchers have proposed grounded theory in tutoring but no one has yet attempted to verify a model. While the original model covered extensive topics such as communication, personal characteristics, outside influences, emotions, temperament, and outcomes, in this brief report we focus mainly on personal characteristics and outside influences. The model fits the data except in the case of asynchronous online tutoring, likely because the original data was from 1983 to 2006 and did not cover much online tutoring.
Published
2019-11-01
Section
Theme 2: The writing centre and online spaces